A beating of a customer by the employees of a club is worth fifteen days of closure, no more. Unless the imposition of the stop is not adequately motivated.
The Tar had anticipated its intentions with an ordinance ( HERE THE NEWS ), now comes the decision on the merits of the appeal presented by the Marinella property, on the Quartu coast.
The text of the device describes in detail what happened on the night of 4 December 2022 in the square outside the business.
We read that "at around 1, in the space in front of the public establishment, an attack occurred which required the intervention of the Flying Squad, during which a young man was lying on the ground and had evident bruises on his face with consequent leakage of blood substance". In short: his face was bloodied.
Because shortly before "the young man was inside the public establishment and had also been accompanied outside by the owner himself". Here "he was attacked by local staff, suffering personal injuries with a 30-day prognosis due to" closed pulmonary trauma and fracture of the nasal pyramid ".
A private citizen had called the police. The administrative judges underlined "that the same place had been the scene in the previous months of an event that caused particular alarm: a young man who had been denied access to the place drove a car at high speed, risking running over several passers-by up to 'investment of a person who suffered several fractures”. An episode dating back to August, which was captured on video.
For the constituency of Piazza del Carmine, therefore, the dynamics of the facts are indisputable. But the closure for 20 days that had been ordered before Christmas by the Cagliari commissioner is judged excessive. Because to suspend a license for more than 15 days it is necessary that there are "particular, specifically motivated public order and safety needs". And the provision issued against Marinella had not been adequately motivated.
Henry Fresu
