LEGGI IL QUOTIDIANO
LEGGI IL QUOTIDIANOOggi 19 November
L'Unione Sarda English
Abbonati
ITA|ENG|DEU|RUS|CIN
videolina Linkradiolina linkSardegna 1 linkVai online linkPBM link
Read the newspaper
L'Unione Sarda English
Subscribe
L'Unione Sarda

Iniziative Editoriali

  • Biblioteca dell'identità

Account

  • Abbonati
  • LEGGI IL QUOTIDIANO
ABBONATI A L’UNIONE SARDA

SCARICA L'APP L'UNIONE DIGITAL

Download GoogleDownload apple
videolina Linkradiolina linkVai online linkPBM link

2021 L'Unione Sarda S.p.A. Tutti i diritti riservati. É vietata la riproduzione, anche parziale e con qualsiasi mezzo, di tutti i materiali del sito. | Indirizzo della Sede Legale: Piazzetta L'Unione Sarda nr. 24 | Capitale sociale 11.400.000,00 i.v. | Codice Fiscale ed iscrizione presso l'Ufficio Registro Imprese di Cagliari 01687830925 (P.I. 02544190925) | REA: CA-136248

Cookie e Privacy PolicyModifica impostazioni privacyInformativa commentiCorporate
L'Unione Sarda

News

  • Cronaca Sardegna
  • Economia
  • Salute
  • Cultura
  • Sport
  • Gossip
  • Turismo

Servizi

  • Necrologi
  • Annunci
  • Pubblicità
  • Contatti

Bella Sardegna

  • Spiagge

Iniziative Editoriali

  • Biblioteca dell'identità

Account

  • Abbonati
  • LEGGI IL QUOTIDIANO
ABBONATI A L’UNIONE SARDA

SCARICA L'APP L'UNIONE DIGITAL

Download GoogleDownload apple
videolina Linkradiolina linkVai online linkPBM link

2021 L'Unione Sarda S.p.A. Tutti i diritti riservati. É vietata la riproduzione, anche parziale e con qualsiasi mezzo, di tutti i materiali del sito. | Indirizzo della Sede Legale: Piazzetta L'Unione Sarda nr. 24 | Capitale sociale 11.400.000,00 i.v. | Codice Fiscale ed iscrizione presso l'Ufficio Registro Imprese di Cagliari 01687830925 (P.I. 02544190925) | REA: CA-136248

Cookie e Privacy PolicyModifica impostazioni privacyInformativa commentiCorporate
HomeSardinia
the verdict

Abbanoa, the sentence: «Illegitimate tax injunctions»

The Lanusei Court rules in favor of a consumer who had contested the blocking of accounts and forced execution. The company: «Correct procedure, ready to appeal»
Enrico Fresu
18 ottobre 2024 alle 14:41
Abbanoa, the sentence: «Illegitimate tax injunctions»
Un ufficio Abbanoa
Resta informato su WhatsApp
FacebookXLinkedInWhatsApp

«Illegitimate»: Abbanoa cannot resort to tax injunctions to recover credits claimed against users. It cannot therefore block current accounts and demand payment within 30 days of often very significant sums, with the “threat” of forced execution. It is not entitled to do so: this is stated in a ruling of the Court of Lanusei of October 16, which ruled in favor of a consumer who, in 2019, received an injunction for 2,508.28 euros. NC, from Tortolì, had turned to the lawyer Sabina Biancu (who is also president of Adoc Ogliastra), who first won before the Justice of the Peace, then defeated Abbanoa, which had filed an appeal to the ordinary Court.

Possible appeal

The legal case may not be over: the Spa dell'acqua has already announced that it will evaluate the appeal of the verdict, underlining that «the sentence does not create jurisprudence and remains applied to the individual case. On tax injunctions, a tool that Abbanoa uses in extreme cases to recover what is due for the regularly guaranteed service, there are now numerous provisions of the Courts that confirm their legitimacy». In this case, however, the outcome was the opposite.

The tax injunction is an extreme, particularly aggressive instrument that public bodies use in the case of multiple defaulters and when all attempts to recover the amount claimed have failed: from friendly notices to registered letters.

In his first appeal, the lawyer Biancu had argued that Abbanoa had asked his client for money for expired bills and that, above all, the water service manager is not a public body, even if it is an in-house company controlled by the Region and Municipalities, and therefore cannot use the weapon of injunctions. His thesis was accepted first by the Justice of the Peace and then by the Court.

The sentence

Judge Giada Rutili writes that the tax injunction can only be used by "the State, territorial bodies and other public bodies" and by "those specifically established through subsequent provisions that similarly allow the direct forced collection of particular revenues". While the rule that establishes it "cannot be applied to different and additional subjects, not expressly contemplated, for the collection of credits generated in the inter-private sphere". And there is a contract between Abbanoa and the users. Therefore the "tax injunctions issued by the concessionary companies of the water service (...) can only be said to be illegitimate".

Abbanoa is sure they are in the right anyway: "The company was authorized by the Ministry of Economy and Finance", it is explained in a note, according to which "the legitimacy of this authorization was recognized first of all by the TAR, which already in April 2016 rejected a request for suspension of the authorization to issue tax injunctions by a consumer association. Another association saw its request to inhibit the use of the injunction tool rejected". The company concludes: "The judges have emphasized on several occasions the correctness of the manager's debt collection actions".

© All rights reserved

Argomenti similiSLOT_2
  • Un clic per uccidere
    Caffè Scorretto

    Un clic per uccidere

    Tacitus

Articoli correlati

Ryanair also cuts flights to Sardinia: "The region isn't keeping its promises."
transportation

Ryanair also cuts flights to Sardinia: "The region isn't keeping its promises."

Another bombshell about the air travel system: "The announced boarding tax cut has not been implemented. Is your connectivity in chaos? Obviously, you're not honoring your commitments."
Enrico Fresu
"He owes me €150 for that repair": Fake plumber attempts scam
in handcuffs

"He owes me €150 for that repair": Fake plumber attempts scam

The Carabinieri of Nuxis and Teulada caught him while he was trying to scam a resident. Several residents had already reported him.
Monserrato, flames on Via Seneca: two cars damaged
the fire

Monserrato, flames on Via Seneca: two cars damaged

Carabinieri investigations
Antonio Serreli
Capoterra: Over a kilo of cocaine found in the house: a man arrested.
drug dealing

Capoterra: Over a kilo of cocaine found in the house: a man arrested.

He tried in vain to get rid of 22 doses ready for sale. The Carabinieri also seized marijuana and hashish.
The Via Quirra market, operators say, "It's falling apart, urgent repairs are needed."
is mirrionis

The Via Quirra market, operators say, "It's falling apart, urgent repairs are needed."

There are many problems with the municipal building: the escalator has been broken for ages, the facade, the bathrooms with broken doors.
Andrea Artizzu
Farouk Kassam: The Anatomy of a Kidnapping That Remains in the Spotlight
the case

Farouk Kassam: The Anatomy of a Kidnapping That Remains in the Spotlight

The TV series' lights and shadows: a family's tragedy takes center stage. During those 177 days, the Island rebelled.
Caterina De Roberto
Cagliari: A car and a scooter collide on Via Cadello.
the accident

Cagliari: A car and a scooter collide on Via Cadello.

One injured in critical condition, with repercussions on traffic
ELENA MANCA
Ozierese-Thiesi: A defender is taken ill on the pitch.
fear

Ozierese-Thiesi: A defender is taken ill on the pitch.

Giovanni Canu, defender of the Canary Islands team, suddenly felt ill and collapsed in the playing area
Mariangela Pala
Triei, Giovanni Secci, and his giant: the 2,550-gram porcini mushroom.
the giant mushroom

Triei, Giovanni Secci, and his giant: the 2,550-gram porcini mushroom.

The discovery was made during a walk among the holm oaks, in one of the areas most frequented by prospectors in the Ogliastra region.
Roberto Secci