The Cagliari Criminal Chamber adheres to the ban on hearings and all judicial activity proclaimed by the Union of Italian Criminal Chambers from November 23 to 27. The announcement was made in a statement released on November 16, in which the criminal lawyers urge the Chamber of Deputies not to definitively approve the reform amending Article 24 of the Constitution.
The bill introduces, immediately after the inviolability of the right to defense, the phrase "The Republic protects victims of crime." This amendment was approved with near-unanimous support and presented as an act of civility. For Cagliari's criminal lawyers, however, justice reforms are not judged by consensus or emotional strength, but by their consistency with constitutional principles and the guarantees of due process.
According to the Criminal Chamber, the provision alters the balance of the criminal process, which serves to impartially determine a citizen's responsibility, not to satisfy a punitive claim. The heart of the process, the lawyers argue, is the accused, over whom the state exercises the most invasive power: it investigates, accuses, limits personal freedom, and can impose punishment. Constitutional guarantees, they point out, are not a privilege of the accused but a defense against miscarriages of justice and abuse of public power.
Among the risks identified are the undermining of institutions and guarantees seen as obstacles to the victim's interests, the questioning of decisions aimed at the offender's rehabilitation, and a punishment that is increasingly less rehabilitative and more symbolic or retributive. They define it as a "cultural, even more than a legal, setback."
Criminal lawyers emphasize that they consider it necessary to pay attention to those who suffer a crime, already protected, they note, by Article 24 and the mechanisms for participating in the proceedings. The problem, they add, is that victims are often left alone: they wait years for a response, encounter obstacles in compensation, and lack adequate psychological, social, and legal support. Concrete measures are needed, not constitutional amendments with a strong symbolic impact.
The Criminal Chamber invites lawyers, magistrates, scholars, and citizens to reflect on the reform and announces that in the coming days it will report on the initiatives organized to mark the abstention.
The reasons for the Union
The abstention, proclaimed by the Union of Italian Criminal Chambers, aims to alert the Chamber of Deputies not to approve the proposed constitutional amendment AC 2197-B in the second and final deliberation. Attorney Giuseppe Ledda , a member of the Union's Executive Committee, speaks about it.
What is your assessment of the reform?
Victim protection is a shared need, but amendment is unnecessary: the Constitution and the Code of Criminal Procedure already recognize the rights and ability of the injured party to participate. The problem is effectiveness. Lengthy trials, delayed compensation, and a lack of assistance cannot be resolved with a provision of primarily symbolic value.
Does supporting the victim's right to defense undermine the balance of the process?
Yes, this is the most delicate aspect. The right to defense limits the state's punitive power. Adding victim protection to it can generate interpretative tensions and lead to a reduction in defense guarantees.
Is there a risk of privatization of the process?
The trial has a public function: to determine responsibility in accordance with the rules. Punishment cannot be a means of personal satisfaction for the victim. A constitutionally strengthened role for the injured party risks transforming the trial into a clash between victim and defendant, and must be coordinated with the presumption of innocence.
Which of the defendant's guarantees are most at risk?
Inadmissibility of evidence, statute of limitations, probation, and alternative measures to detention. If the victim's interest in conviction were to be a parameter, restrictive interpretations could arise. Defense and the presumption of innocence protect all citizens, especially the innocent.
What would the victims really need?
Rapid compensation, psychological, social, and legal assistance, more information on proceedings, and protection tools for those who report. Above all, trials of reasonable length and a functioning judicial system. These two safeguards, he concludes, should not be set against each other: the challenge is to implement the rights already recognized by the Constitution.