The progressive decline in births in Italy, from over one million in the first half of the 1960s to just 355,000 in 2025, has led to a decidedly negative population balance, with deaths exceeding births by 300,000 annually. This is causing population imbalances and gaps that risk becoming unsustainable and which, according to some, have only been prevented from becoming so dramatic thanks to the contribution of migration. But this creates a phenomenon with which our country must now grapple: "ethnic substitution," a phenomenon that too often goes unreported and sparks discussions with a distinctly ideological tone.
Statistician Roberto Volpi , who has been studying our country's demographic issues for years, has decided to tackle this highly divisive process with the flair of a scholar accustomed to analyzing numbers.
This is how "Chronicles from 'ethnic substitution'" (Lindau, 2026, pp. 152, also e-book) was born, in which the author first offers us a precise definition of this phenomenon.
Ethnic substitution is an overly demonized term, filled with extreme ideological content that claims it is the product of a conspiracy, no one knows by whom and on what scale, to oust white Western populations from their positions of preeminence. Beyond the silliness, it is a process whereby, when a country experiences a profound and prolonged trend of population loss due to excessively low birth rates and the resulting increasingly marked excess of deaths over births, a migratory flow of people from other countries consolidates, under certain conditions. While it tends, so to speak, to stem the population losses of the country in question, it also causes a progressive change in its ethnic composition: inhabitants of other origins and ethnic groups are grafted onto the original population.
Beyond ideologies, is it correct to speak of ethnic substitution for Italy?
In my book, I obviously talk about Italy, but even more so, a French or German demographer might speak of ethnic substitution in France and Germany, respectively. Although the birth rate has been less severe than in Italy, the birth-death ratio is largely negative, and the incoming migration flows into these countries are as significant, if not more so, than ours. It's correct to speak of ethnic substitution—this is the point that needs to be clearly understood—when, without those migration flows, a population like the Italian one, following the loss of inhabitants due to the imbalance between births and deaths, would soon find itself unable to provide for itself, as it would be unable to run factories or agriculture, care for the elderly, or sustain the vitality and future of the country, condemning itself to decline.
What are the dimensions and characteristics of the ethnic substitution phenomenon in Italy?
"Both in the last twenty-five and five years, the population I defined in my book as 'with the potential for ethnic substitution' has increased in Italy by an average of 300,000 people per year, which is why we can expect a similar size of the phenomenon in the immediate future. This population will reach 9 million in 2025, with just under 50 percent of it coming from Europe and just over 50 percent from other continents. Lately, Asian countries in particular have been increasing their presence in Italy."
Will ethnic substitution save the Italian population demographically?
No, it won't save it, if by saving you mean getting us out of trouble once and for all and preparing a future for us where we will no longer have fears and demographic failures. But it will save it, if by saving you mean allowing the country to sort of parachute-land instead of crashing to the ground without any protection. The Italian population will continue to decline, but it will be a slow, diluted, and postponed decline, in a certain sense bearable.
Which areas of our country are most affected by the phenomenon and which are least?
What happens with ethnic substitution is what happens with almost all economic and social phenomena without exception: the dualism between the Center-North and the South. But to an even more marked extent. The strength of the economic-productive system is decisive in attracting migratory flows to Italy, and this explains why ethnic substitution is decidedly more pronounced in the North than in the South. There is also another aspect. It is the city, and especially the large city, where the opportunities and chances for self-realization are greater, that attract young migrants. And the large city is decidedly more present and vibrant in the North than in the South.
Is it possible to control ethnic substitution, or is it a phenomenon we should be afraid of?
If we simply feared the phenomenon of ethnic substitution, we would be literally doomed because, as I said, we need it. And yet, it is a matter that must be handled with care and cannot be left to its own devices. In other words, the phenomenon must be governed, and to do so, and to do so well, requires political will and capacity, above all. One necessity stands out: migratory flows will increasingly need to be planned through agreements with the countries from which migrants originate, and from which we intend them to originate. The time for improvisation and free-for-all in this area is over forever. Even if many, too many, show they still haven't understood this.