«No mere imprudence or inexperience in calculating the danger and the means of salvation was found in the action» of Mario Roggero, who «with a voluntary and conscious choice, channelled his action along the lines of a deliberate aggression not justified by the need for defence» .
This was written by the judges of the first criminal section in the reasons for the ruling of July 15, which finalized the 14-year and 9-month sentence for the jeweler from Grinzane Cavour (Cuneo), accused of killing two robbers and wounding a third after the attack on his shop on April 28, 2021.
"Further behavior was considered unequivocally indicative of Roggero's intention to take justice into his own hands . Moreover, the defendant himself had stated in interviews given after the incident that the initiative he had taken was the only way to stop the robbers and bring them to justice," the Supreme Court judges added.
In its reasoning, the Court of Cassation also states that "the contested ruling correctly excluded the existence of legitimate defense, real or presumed, on the basis of a prudent assessment of the specific situation in which the defendant found himself, deemed such as not to legitimise the emergence of the belief that one must defend oneself or others from an unjust attack and to make harmful action necessary."
The judges wrote that "Roggero had chased the robbers outside the jewelry store, firing gunshots at a moment when the robbery was already concluded and the criminals were intent on fleeing."
And again: «The homicidal conduct was carried out at a time when the danger to the life and personal safety of the relatives had by now ceased , as the accused himself had clearly perceived».
According to the Supreme Court, therefore, "the intent to commit murder was inferred from the rapid succession of multiple gunshots, fired at chest height and from close range, in the direction of the injured parties."
(Unioneonline)











